Attribute Family

Core definition#

Attribute frames profile a property, dimension or value of a single bearer. A bearer may be an entity, event or proposition. The property is not defined through an ongoing maintaining force or a producing event.

ATTRIBUTE(Bearer, Dimension, Value)

"No producing-event dependence" is a claim about lexical/frame meaning, not about physical history. A green wall can have been painted: that contextual fact does not turn the colour frame into State.

The family has five namespaces. They split by the structure of the value: a position against a standard, a measured quantity, a category, a modal profile, or an operation on another predicate. They do not split by what the property is about: colour, health, morality or cost are recorded by the domain, and each appears in several namespaces.

Namespace Value structure Examples
Gradable A position on a scale, against a relative or absolute standard Size, Desirability, Temperature, Difficulty, Duration_description
Measured_value A quantity: count of units, number, ratio, sum, or the unit itself Dimension, Measure_mass, Cardinal_numbers, Quantity, Proportion, Duration_relation
Classifying A non-gradable category of a dimension Description_oriented_by_body_part, Color, Shapes, Legality, Gender_identity_descriptor
Modal What can, must, should or tends to happen with the bearer Capability, Possibility, Likelihood, Inclination, Required_event
Modifier An operation on another predicate, not a property of an entity Degree, Proportional_quantity, Judgment_of_intensity, Manner

These namespaces classify how a frame structures the region its values occupy. A frame that names the quality itself, the dimension rather than a value (moralidade rather than moral), is in the Quality namespace, outside this family. Many frames still contain lemmas of both types (beleza and belo, cor and azul); the lemma types are not namespace criteria, and such mixed frames are reviewed reading by reading.

Gradable#

The bearer has a position on a scale that holds against a standard. The standard can be relative to a comparison class (alto, caro, bonito) or absolute, fixed by an endpoint of the scale (completo, cheio, seco). Degree modifiers and comparatives apply. Evaluative properties (desirability, morality, usefulness) and traits judged from behaviour are Gradable when the frame attributes a scalar value to one bearer.

FrameNet keeps measure phrases out of Measurable_attributes (really tall) and puts them in Dimension (10 feet tall); the same split separates Gradable from Measured_value.

Measured_value#

The value is given as a quantity: a count of units (10 metros, trĂŞs quilos), a number, a ratio or rate, a total, a range between limits, or the unit itself (metro, hora, quilo). Transparent quantity nouns (pilha, punhado) and numeric odds belong here. Units of measure stay in this namespace rather than Entity because they exist to give a value to another entity.

Classifying#

A non-gradable property places the bearer in a category of a dimension: relational adjectives (pulmonar, argiloso, automobilĂ­stico), identity descriptors (gender, race, sexual orientation, sex, life stage), legal or religious status (ilegal, sagrado), types of shape, pattern and hair configuration, phases of matter and the basic colour terms as regions of colour space.

Relational adjectives that sort the noun by domain (material escolar, turismo sexual, exame médico) go to the Classifying frame Domain, even when the domain is named after an activity: escolar evokes no teacher, student or teaching. See Property adjectives and event frames.

Frames whose LUs mix categorical and gradable readings (colour terms with claro/escuro, frequency adjectives with frequente/raro) are placed by their predominant reading and recorded for review.

The property of a single bearer is defined by what can, must, should or tends to happen with it: capability and capacity, access, possibility and likelihood, propensity and susceptibility, habit, destiny, risk, and requirement or desirability of a single situation (deve, tem que applied to one state of affairs).

Adjectives in -ável/-ível follow the event-frame test: when the noun fills an FE of the event (doença curável is the Affliction of Cure, roupa lavável the Theme of washing), the LU belongs in the event frame; Possibility keeps the readings that state bare possibility (possível, viável, concebível).

A modal meaning with two core relata, such as a responsible party and a duty or a dependent situation and its requirement, belongs to Dependency. A thinker's confidence is Experiencer_state, and imposing a duty as an action is Agentive.

Modifier#

The LUs modify another predicate instead of ascribing a property to an entity: intensifiers (muito, extremamente), approximators (cerca de, quase), adjectives grading the intensity of an attribute noun (grave, forte), manner (tranquilamente) and expectation markers (inteiro, mero).

Quality frames#

Decided 2026-11-12. DUL separates a Quality, an aspect inhering in a bearer (this person's morality, sexuality or health), from the Region it takes (moral, homossexual, doente) and from Abstract entities such as doctrines and fields. Two non-lexical anchors carry the distinction:

Anchor Its frames Example frames
Attributes (Entity, Attribute, Value) ascribe a value to a bearer; the Value is profiled Morality_evaluation, Sexual_orientation_descriptor, Measurable_attributes
Quality (Bearer, Quality, Value), used by Attributes (Quality → Attribute) name the quality itself; the Quality is profiled and incorporated in the LU Morality, Sexuality

Quality frames are in the Quality namespace (2026-11-12), outside the Attribute family: their value structure belongs to the attribute frames that ascribe the values. Morality and Sexuality moved there from Classifying. The frames for people, events and doctrines related to a quality stay where they are (People_by_sexual_orientation, Sex, Ideology). See LU Allocation Rules, R11.

Health conditions stay State until the Health domain model is reviewed, and emotion and cognition nouns stay in the Experiential family.

Boundaries#

  • State: maintenance or resultant-condition dependence is constitutive. Being broken differs from plain colour attribution. Frames that sit in a causative/inchoative family (Being_dry with Becoming_dry and Cause_to_be_dry) are evaluated as State. Do not infer a producing event solely from morphology or general world knowledge.
  • Experiential family: a thinker's certainty, emotional state or felt sensation requires psychological/sensory content and constitutive sentience. Mental vocabulary alone is insufficient; general trait/disposition cases need definition-based review.
  • Relation family: a frame goes to Relation only when its core FEs include two relata (Figure and Ground, Instance and Type, Profiled_item and Standard_item). A standard or comparison set mentioned with one bearer keeps the frame here.
  • Agentive, Change and Undergoing: a property adjective stays in an event frame when the modified noun fills an FE of the event; otherwise it is Attribute (test).
  • Entity: naming a participant category (mĂ©dico) differs from naming a property (altura) or value (alto), even in predicative use.
  • Quality: a frame that names the quality itself (moralidade) is Quality; a frame that ascribes its values (moral) stays here.
  • Dynamic categories: becoming warm, heating something and warmth holding are distinct meanings.
  • Pragmatic: an interactional stance operation differs from describing likelihood or a speaker's mental condition.

Property adjectives and event frames#

Decided 2026-11-11. An adjective whose lemma is a value may evoke an event frame (Lemmas §8). Which frame it belongs to is decided by one test:

An adjective stays in the event frame when its reading evokes the event with its participants, so that the noun it modifies fills an FE of the event. When it only sorts the noun into a category, with no participant of the event in view, it is Attribute.

Reading The modified noun Frame
arma letal Instrument of killing Killing (stays)
doença curável Affliction of Cure Cure (stays)
pessoa vingativa the Avenger, as a disposition Revenge (stays)
substância cancerígena Cause of the disease the event frame (stays)
material escolar no teacher, student or teaching Domain (Classifying)
turismo sexual, exame médico sorted by domain Domain (Classifying)
frango Ă  milanesa, pĂŁo artesanal sorted by how it was made Production_mode_descriptor (Classifying)
  • Relational adjectives (pulmonar, automobilĂ­stico, escolar) are Classifying. When the dimension is the field or activity the noun belongs to, the frame is Domain.
  • Potential and -ável/-Ă­vel adjectives (letal, terapĂŞutico, curável, reciclável) usually pass the test and stay in the event frame, as FrameNet keeps lethal in Killing and curable in Cure. Possibility and the Modal potential frames hold the readings that do not name a specific event.
  • Traits and evaluations (vaidoso, dissimulado, prestativo) are decided per lemma: when the event-frame LU and an Attribute LU of the same lemma name the same trait, one of them is redundant.
  • The test reads the LU's sense, not its lemma type or its morphology. A suffix such as -ável, -ivo or -or is a cue, never a verdict.

Characteristic signature and grounding#

Role Contribution
Entity / Bearer What is characterized
Attribute / Dimension The relevant quality axis
Value Position or region on that axis
Standard / Degree Comparison basis or extent, where represented
Count / Unit Measured quantity, in Measured_value

The Attributes schema relates Entity, Attribute and Value for the whole family. Actual FE names and core/core-unexpressed status depend on the frame. The template does not justify copying one anchor's FE inventory into every member.

Diagnostic examples#

  • JoĂŁo Ă© alto: Gradable (relative standard).
  • O copo está cheio: Gradable (absolute standard), unless the frame profiles a resultant condition (State).
  • A torre tem 10 metros: Measured_value.
  • Uma dor lombar: Classifying.
  • A cor da parede Ă© verde: Classifying; um verde muito escuro: Gradable.
  • É provável que chova: Modal, without a Cognizer.
  • Muito cansado: Modifier for muito.
  • JoĂŁo sabe que chove: cognition, hence Experiencer_state.
  • O livro está na caixa: a relation between two relata, hence Localization.

Gradability, comparison and X tem uma propriedade paraphrases support analysis but cannot decide alone. Preserve frame coherence; do not let one causal or comparative example reclassify a mixed frame. Defer measurement/comparison, disposition and property/condition overlaps where the definition is insufficient. See Frames.