Type classification for lemmas
Each lexical lemma is assigned one type under this model; punctuation and symbols are outside its scope (§6), and untyped records require review rather than a guessed value. The type vocabulary has two sorts: ontological types, for lemmas that encode a concept, and procedural types, for lemmas that encode an instruction for processing. Which sort a lemma takes is the first type-classification decision; it does not decide the lemma's LU senses or their allocations.
A lemma here is a lexeme: a citation form paired with a part of speech, not a bare string. A lexical unit (LU) records a reading of a lemma in a frame, carrying a sense description. Lemmas and frames have a many-to-many relationship. Shared lemma/frame IDs are duplicate-candidate evidence, not proof that two LU records represent the same reading. The type belongs to the lemma and only to the lemma. The LU inherits it and carries no type of its own, so creating an LU involves no typing decision at all.
What this layer claims, and what it does not#
Four scoping commitments govern every assignment in this document.
- The type is a property of the lemma â a lexeme identified by language, text, POS and any homograph distinction â not of a word form or a referent. POS already does the construal-fixing work: colar/VERB and colar/NOUN are different lexemes with different meanings before any frame is consulted.
- The type classifies a conceptual profile, not the furniture of the world. No claim is made about what exists. This follows the grounding ontology: DOLCE is a Descriptive Ontology, an inventory of particulars as conceptualized by natural language, explicitly neutral on metaphysics. Typing a lemma against DUL types a conceptualization against a catalogue of conceptualizations.
- The type is a coarse, defeasible default, serving as the input to constructional composition and coercion. A construction may override it â override is the interesting data, not a counterexample, since a function needs an argument. The default lives in the lexicon and is defeated in use.
- The type is a comparative concept, in Haspelmath's sense: an FNBr-internal instrument for cross-frame, cross-resource and cross-linguistic alignment â not a descriptive category of Portuguese, and not a metaphysical claim.
Because the type is defeasible (commitment 3), and because it does not restrict which frames a lemma's LUs evoke (§8), a type that looks unusual for a frame is not by itself an error.
1. Parts of speech and the locus of the type#
1.1 Why retain POS at all#
The theoretical case against parts of speech as a semantic category is strong: syntactic categories are language-particular and construction-derived (Croft, Radical Construction Grammar), and do not translate across languages as descriptive categories (Haspelmath 2010). This is why the type layer exists and why it is not a POS layer.
POS is nonetheless retained: it is load-bearing for lemmatization and morphological analysis, MWE and terminology identification, corpus query (word sketches are defined over POS patterns), and interoperability with UD, LMF and OntoLex-Lemon/LexInfo.
The architecture follows OntoLex-Lemon: POS is morphosyntactic metadata on the lexical entry; the type is the conceptual layer, linked by semantics-by-reference. Both sit on the lemma; neither pretends to be the other.
1.2 POS is part of lemma identity#
POS is part of lexical-entry identity, together with language and any homograph distinction. The following is a logical identity model, not a claim about physical column names or implemented database constraints:
lemma(id, text, pos, lang, homograph_idx, type_id)
UNIQUE(text, pos, lang, homograph_idx)
form (id, text, lemma_id, feats) -- the paradigm of ONE lemma entry
lu (id, lemma_id, frame_id, sense_description)
Keying lemma on text alone conflates distinct lexemes. Colar is two
lemmas: colar/VERB ("to glue"), whose paradigm contains colo, colei,
colando; and colar/NOUN ("necklace"), whose paradigm is colar,
colares. With a text-only key, a parse of Eu colo o papel would resolve
colo to a single colar row and make the noun sense reachable from a verb
form â a lemma that does not exist.
Two consequences:
- Form lookup is set-valued.
form.text â {lemma_id}returns candidates. POS is what filters them, but POS lives on the token, not on the form string: parsing the sentence assigns the token a UPOS, and matching that against the POS carried by each candidate lemma picks the right one. Colo is itself ambiguous off any list â it is a form ofcolar/VERBand also a noun in its own right (colo/NOUN, "lap") â so the string alone does not resolve it. A reliable token POS can exclude the noun/verb mismatch, but homographs and readings sharing that POS still require disambiguation. - When UPOS is absent or unreliable, do not guess at the lemma layer. Return the candidate set and let frame matching decide. POS narrows; it does not adjudicate.
homograph_idx distinguishes lemmas that share text and POS: genuine
homonymy (manga fruit/sleeve) and type divergence, where one form
under one POS carries readings of different types. Default 0. It is not
used for polysemy within a single type â that is what LUs are for (§1.4).
FNBr's entry convention uses pos = X for MWE entries, with
entry_type â {word, mwe, affix} distinguishing entry kinds. This is a local
lexicon convention, not a claim that UD requires X for every MWE: an expression
can have a syntactic category while its components receive individual POS tags.
The expression's conceptual/procedural type is a separate question.
X, not null. A null POS propagates: view_lu derives an LU's display
name as concat(lemma.name, udpos.suffix), and concat() returns null when
any argument is â so a null POS silently blanks the rendered name. X carries
a real suffix, so dar um jeito renders as dar um jeito.x. Every lemma
carries a POS; a lemma arriving without one is assigned X rather than left
null under the entry convention. The nullable storage field means existing
missing-POS records still need validation; this documentation does not repair
them or authorize replacing their identity automatically.
1.3 Why the type belongs to the lemma#
Three reasons, one theoretical and two practical.
The lexeme is already a formâmeaning pairing. Once POS is part of lemma
identity, most of the construal-fixing work is already done before any frame
is consulted. Colarᔄ and colarâ are separate lemmas with separate types;
so are dependenteâ (role) and dependenteâ (value). Putting the type on
the lemmaâframe pairing instead would record, on every LU, a fact constant
across all of a lemma's LUs.
The type is available before frame assignment. A parser can type a token as soon as it resolves the lemma, with no frame in hand â which is precisely when a type is most useful as a filter.
It matches the FrameNet data model. The LU table is a lemma Ă frame association with a sense description. A mandatory type column there would make the LU a second lexical entry rather than a pairing.
1.4 Type divergence and lemma identity#
Within a language and lexical identity, established readings of different types require separate lemma identities. Readings sharing a type can remain under one lemma and be distinguished as LUs. Genuine homonyms may remain separate even when text, POS and type coincide.
One type per lemma; type equality alone does not establish lemma identity.
This is the only mechanism for type divergence in the specification â there is no LU-level type and no override.
- Creating an LU involves no typing decision. The annotator pairs a lemma with a frame and writes a sense description; the type arrived with the lemma.
- Stored assignments are reviewable. The intended single-valued type does not make the data correct by construction. Missing types, misallocated LUs, mixed readings and rule limitations must be distinguished before splitting. Namespace diversity alone does not authorize a lemma split.
The split is bounded by type, not by sense count: de has at least six distinguishable readings but only two types, so it yields two lemmas, not six (§6.2).
Three case shapes are known:
- Cross-sort polysemy. Negação names the act of denying (
event, in an@agentiveframe) and the propositional operator (polarity) ânegaçãoâevent,negaçãoâpolarity. - Product nominalization. Pintura as the activity is
event; as the canvas on the wall it isobject. Same for construção, tradução, invenção, criação, publicação â deverbal nominals whose event produces an artifact that outlives it. Not all deverbal nominals: see §4. - Adpositions. De, a, em, por, com, para â the largest group, worked through in §6.2.
Not for:
- Construal shifts. A lemma can be referred to, or otherwise used, in a
way that leaves part of its normal profile inactive without the stored
type changing â the type is a fact about the lemma; the construal is a
fact about the occurrence. Pai used to pick out an individual with no
relation in play is still the
rolelemma: the relation is simply not invoked by that use. Löbner's determiner-triggered readings are the best-studied case, but the mechanism is not limited to determiners â see the next bullet. Per commitment 3, a construal shift is defeasance in use, not a second type â and, since nothing about the lemma itself changed, not a second lemma either. - Substantivized adjectives used elliptically. O bonito, um
americano pick out an entity the adjective characterizes â a person, a
car, whatever the covert head recovers as â via the construction that lets
any adjective head an NP under a determiner with its head noun elided.
This is a construal shift like the one above: bonito and americano
stay
value, and which entity the value is predicated of is a frame-level fact (§7), not a lemma-level one. The test: can the use be regenerated as "[some contextually recoverable sortal] that is ADJ," with the adjective keeping its ordinary value? If the covert head is freely recoverable and swappable by context, it is a construal shift and the adjective lemma is untouched. If the "noun" reading is fixed regardless of context and carries content the adjective does not â typically a specific institutional or relational profile â the use has lexicalized, and §1.2's POS split applies instead: dependenteâ ("meu dependente", aroleâ someone for whom a specific provider must exist) is a different lemma from dependenteâ ("ele Ă© dependente",value), not a construal shift of it (§7). - Polysemy within a type. Readings can share a typed lemma while requiring different LU analyses. Genitive, material and partitive uses of de need no LUs: their relation is evoked by the head or by a construction (§6.2). Neither multiple frames nor a screening conflict alone establishes type divergence.
Splitting is the same operation as homonymy handling, deliberately:
manga fruit/sleeve and deâ/deâ can both require separate lexical identities.
The reason for separation and relatedness of the entries still need evidence;
type classification does not erase a genuine homonym distinction.
A split records no relation between the two lemmas. Where relatedness
matters â negação act/operator, pintura activity/canvas â it belongs at
the lexical layer as an explicit link (OntoLex-Lemon's vartrans module),
not as a shared row.
1.5 POS and type are not orthogonal#
Deverbal nominalizations and participles show strong type/POS correlation, because category is assigned in a structure that also determines event structure. The claim is narrower: the type is not derivable from POS and not reducible to it. How much independent information it carries is answerable by a POS Ă type contingency table, since both columns live on the same row.
2. The two sorts: conceptual and procedural encoding#
Not every word encodes a concept. Quem, nĂŁo, portanto, o have meanings, but those meanings are not things classifiable as objects, events or qualities â the "world thing" is computed in context, if at all.
Relevance Theory supplies the distinction. Blakemore (Semantic Constraints on Relevance, 1987) and Wilson & Sperber ("Linguistic form and relevance", Lingua 1993) distinguish conceptual encoding â the expression contributes a constituent to the proposition expressed â from procedural encoding â the expression encodes an instruction for processing: a constraint on inference, reference resolution, or how to build or access a representation. Discourse connectives, indexicals, polarity, and most grammatical morphemes are procedural on this analysis.
FNBr adopts the distinction as the top branch of the type vocabulary:
| Sort | Encodes | Gets an ontological type | Gets a DUL reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| conceptual | a concept | yes (§3) | yes |
| procedural | an instruction for processing | no | no |
Procedural lemmas carry no DUL reference â there is nothing in the conceptualization inventory for them to reference, because they name an operation on a conceptualized particular, not the particular itself.
3. The ontological types#
Six types. Each grounds in a DUL class. There are no parameters.
| Type | DUL grounding | Criterion | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
event |
dul:Event |
occurs or happens: it exists in time, has (or can have) temporal parts, and does not persist unchanged | destruição, aquecer, correr, quebrar, derreter, existir |
object |
dul:Object |
a sortal â it supplies a criterion of identity â whose instances need no other entity to exist | cadeira, ĂĄgua, pessoa, documento, lei, ideia, criança, adulto |
role |
dul:Role â dul:Concept |
a sortal whose instances are externally dependent: some other entity, not a part of them, must exist | comprador, jogador, cliente, filho, pai, proprietĂĄrio, metade |
relation |
dul:Relation â dul:Description |
a reified relation type â a Description that defines the argument positions (roles) it relates | parentesco, paternidade, posse, casamento, adjacĂȘncia, anterioridade |
quality |
dul:Quality |
a dimension â a gradable or categorial axis â that inheres in some bearer | cor, tamanho, beleza, inteligĂȘncia, temperatura, cansaço, postura |
value |
dul:Region â dul:Abstract |
a region or point within a quality's dimension, nameable without presupposing any bearer | azul, quente, bonito, inteligente, cansado, quebrado, sentado, belamente |
The criteria draw on rigidity, sortality, external dependence, and the dimension/region distinction â defined in full in Appendix §A.1.
The reference principle#
The lemma references a conceptualization, never a particular and never a formal object:
- comprador references
dul:Roleâ a Concept that classifies persons â not any person. - parentesco references
dul:Relation, a Description â the relation type â not any particular kinship instance. - adjacĂȘncia and anterioridade reference the commonsense
dul:Relation, not the formal counterpart underdul:FormalEntity.
This is what "semantics by reference" means for a lexicon: the lemma points at a conceptualization, which is exactly what a word does.
role and relation are two halves of one structure#
dul:Relation is a Description; the Concepts filling its argument positions
are dul:isDefinedIn that Description:
| FNBr object | DUL | DnS relation |
|---|---|---|
| Relation frame | dul:Relation â Description |
â |
| FE of that frame | dul:Role / dul:Concept |
dul:isDefinedIn â the Description |
relation lemma (parentesco) |
references the Relation |
â |
role lemma (filho, pai) |
references a Role |
isDefinedIn the same Relation |
Parentesco names the description; filho and pai name Concepts it defines â not two unrelated primitives that happen to sound alike.
The instance layer, where needed, is dul:Situation: the particular
fatherhood holding between two individuals in an annotated sentence is a
Situation that dul:satisfies the Relation. Lemma layer â Description;
annotation layer â Situation â the same coarse-identity/fine-situation
asymmetry the whole model runs on (§7).
Role definition is not lexicalization home. A role can be defined in a relation while its participant-denoting LU evokes an Entity frame. FNBr requires this for agentive names. Record the participant association separately; see FrameNet patterns.
Converse pairs require semantic evidence. Shared isDefinedIn links identify
roles in a common relation, but do not alone establish which roles are converses.
Rigidity is not used as a typing axis, and abstract nouns do not get a type of their own â both are informational notes rather than operative rules; see Appendix §A.2 and §A.3.
4. Conceptual diagnostics#
The first question: conceptual or procedural?#
Does the lemma contribute a constituent to the proposition, or instruct the hearer how to process one? If the latter, go to §5 and stop.
object / role#
Both are thing-like; one binary test separates them: external dependence.
| Type | Examples | |
|---|---|---|
| not externally dependent | object |
pessoa, cadeira, documento, criança, adulto |
| externally dependent | role |
comprador, filho, presidente, proprietĂĄrio |
Is there an entity y, not a part or constituent of x, whose existence is required for x to be P?
Comprador â yes (a purchase, a seller). Filho â yes (a parent).
Documento â no. Criança â no: being a child requires no second entity, so
it is object, not role, even though an individual stops being one
(Appendix §A.2).
Mere participation is not dependence. Documents get signed, filed and
sent, but no particular event must exist for a document to be a document. If
participation sufficed, every entity noun in the lexicon would be a role.
Two corpus diagnostics, for cases where the ontological test is hard to apply â both operationalize Löbner's [R] (Appendix §A.1):
- Bare predicative:
?Ela é irmãvsEla é médica. A +R concept resists the bare predicative without a recoverable relatum. - De-genitive reading: does de X give an argument (pai de João) or a modifier (carro de João)? Argument readings indicate +R.
These are annotatable and scorable, so the role boundary can be validated
rather than defended by introspection.
Occupations are object; offices are role. Padeiro, médico,
advogado, motorista, professor pass the bare predicative (ela é médica)
and require no particular second entity: practising a trade is
participation, not dependence. An office or rank held in an institution
is role: presidente, senador, vereador, cardeal, abade, coronel,
delegado. Each takes an argument de-genitive (presidente da empresa,
abade do mosteiro), and the office cannot exist without the institution.
The same goes for agentive names tied to one event or relatum (comprador,
autor, vĂtima, acusado, paciente, sĂłcio), whether or not they also
name a job. The Pessoas_por_vocação frame does not decide the type; each
noun takes this test.
Parts are object; fractions are role. A body part or an artifact
part (dedo, tronco, gengiva, roda, telhado) has an identity of its own and
is object, although no finger exists without a hand. The dependence test
targets concepts defined by a relation to another entity, and being a part
of something is not such a relation. A noun that names a fraction of
whatever whole is given (metade, pedaço, fragmento, trecho, décimo) is
role (§6.3).
Sports are event. A sport or discipline is a kind of activity
(atletismo, maratona, salto em altura, squash), and so is a competition
(torneio, campeonato, oitavas). Team positions (goleiro, centroavante,
lĂbero) are role: each is defined in the team.
event / object in deverbal nominals#
A deverbal noun is an event by default and stays one. Nominalization is a
constructional fact: it lets an event concept be referred to, counted,
determined and modified like a thing, without changing what the concept is.
Duas destruiçÔes, a destruição foi total, aquela destruição are all the
event under nominal packaging. Countability, determination, pluralization
and adjectival modification are never evidence for object.
The one case that diverges is a lemma with a product sense: a participant of the event â typically its Result or Product â with existence independent of the event, persisting after it ends.
Does the lemma have a sense denoting a thing that the event produced, rather than the event itself under some construal?
Three tests, all passed by the product sense and failed by the event sense:
- Spatial location. A pintura estå na parede. / *A destruição estå na parede.
- Physical or material predicates. A tradução tem 300 påginas. / *A destruição tem 300 påginas.
- Persistence. The product exists once the event is over; the event does not.
Pintura, construção, tradução, invenção, criação, publicação pass. Destruição, aquecimento, chegada, corrida, viagem fail: they have no product, and their apparent "result" readings are the event's Result or Effect FE reached metonymically â a frame-layer fact, not a type-layer one.
Grimshaw's complex-event/simple-event/result trichotomy is not used here: it separates nominals by argument structure, not by type (Appendix §A.4).
quality / value#
Ask whether the lemma names the dimension or a region within it (Appendix §A.1). Altura/alto, temperatura/quente, beleza/bonito, cansaço/cansado are each a dimension/value pair, decided the same way every time.
No entity is presupposed by either. A temperature scale exists, and a
point on it is nameable, whether or not any object is currently at that
temperature â estĂĄ quente hoje, said of the weather, names no entity at
all. What links a value to the entity bearing it is the job of the
Attributes schema (its Entity, Value and Attribute elements), not of
the lemma's type.
The type does not encode causal origin. Whether a quality resulted from
an event (cansaço, force-maintained postura) or not (beleza,
inteligĂȘncia) plays no role in the classification: both are quality, and
their values â cansado, quebrado, sentado on one side, bonito,
inteligente on the other â are both value. That distinction belongs to
the situation: plain attribution, active maintenance and resultant conditions
must be distinguished from their definitions. Maintained and resultant readings
can both belong to State; plain properties belong to the Attribute family. Sharing a
lemma type does not establish that any specific allocation is correct. See Appendix §A.5 for the full argument, including why no
reliable test separates a "resultant" quality from a non-resultant one.
Referential use does not create a new type. O bonito, um americano refer to an entity characterized by the value without the lemma becoming a different kind of thing â see §1.4, "Substantivized adjectives used elliptically," for the construal-shift diagnostic that tells this apart from genuine lexicalization (dependenteâ/dependenteâ, §7).
Health conditions are quality; episodes are event. A disease or
condition (bradicardia, catarata, alcoolismo, glossite, diabetes) is a
categorial dimension that inheres in a bearer, typed like cansaço. Its
values (doente, diabético, enfermo) are value. A noun naming an
occurrence of the condition (surto, crise, ataque, piora, recaĂda) is
event, like any happening. A lesion, mass or body substance is a thing,
not a condition: cisto, cĂĄlculo, pĂłlipo, variz, pus, catarro are object,
because they pass the spatial-location test (o cisto estĂĄ no ovĂĄrio).
Existing NOUN lemmas for value categories stay value. Demonyms and
nouns for adherents, ages, ethnicities and orientations (brasileiro,
judeu, catĂłlico, idoso, gay) can exist as NOUN lemmas that duplicate
an ADJ value lemma. They keep the value type, as the construal-shift
analysis gives the adjective (§1.4, §7). Merging their LUs onto the ADJ
lemma is LU work, not a typing decision. The doctrine or group itself
(budismo, catolicismo, judaĂsmo) is object, like lei or ideia.
Nouns with no value reading (criança, recém-nascido, mendigo) are sortals,
typed by the object/role test.
relation / role#
The tie is relation (paternidade, posse); the argument position
named as such is role (pai, proprietĂĄrio). Arity and converse
evidence (pai-de â filho-de, posse â pertence-a) confirm a relation
exists; the link between the two is dul:isDefinedIn (§3), not a parameter.
A free-standing referential use of a role noun â pai picking out the
individual who walked in, with no relation in play â is a construal shift,
not a second type. The lemma remains role (§1.4).
5. Procedural types#
Nine types. Procedural lemmas take no DUL reference.
| Type | Encodes | Examples |
|---|---|---|
reference |
how to resolve a referent â deictic, anaphoric, definiteness | o, este, ele, quem, aqui, hoje, agora |
quantification |
how to quantify over a domain â individuals, times or occasions | todo, cada, algum, vĂĄrios, ambos, tudo, qualquer, alguĂ©m, algo, sempre, geralmente, Ă s vezes |
polarity |
assert or deny instantiation | sim, nĂŁo, nunca, jamais, nada, nenhum, nem, sem |
degree |
how to locate a value relative to a standard | muito, pouco, mais, menos, bastante, demais, tĂŁo |
modality |
modal status of the proposition â epistemic, deontic, ability or bouletic (wish) â with no scale named | talvez, necessariamente; modal auxiliaries (poder, dever, ter que, precisar); optatives (oxalĂĄ, tomara, Deus queira, quem me dera); free mood markers |
connection |
inferential or discourse relation between units | contudo, portanto, porém, entretanto, pois, se |
focus |
information-structural instruction, including verum focus and exception | só, também, até, mesmo, sequer, inclusive, exceto, salvo, de fato, realmente |
predication |
how to build the predication; contributes no concept beyond what the head, frame or construction supplies | copulas (ser, estar), tense and aspect auxiliaries (estar + gerund, ir + infinitive, ter + participle), support verbs, case-marking de/a/por |
interaction |
how to manage the exchange â appeal, stance display, information source or perspective, hedging, comment on the speech act | nĂ©, hein, viu, tĂĄ, uĂ©, nossa, olha, tipo, assim, diz que, supostamente, segundo, francamente |
The nine types are organized by functional category; their theoretical provenance and relation to Relevance Theory is in Appendix §A.6.
Notes on the boundaries#
degree vs value. The criterion is whether the lemma names a region
or instructs where to locate one relative to a standard. Quente,
morno, azul name regions â value. Muito, pouco, bastante locate a
region against a contextually supplied standard â degree.
Indefinite pronouns are quantifiers. Tudo, tudo que, qualquer,
qualquer um, qualquer coisa, a qualquer momento, vĂĄria, algo and
alguém quantify over a domain of entities or times, exactly as the
determiners todo and algum do (algo is alguma coisa, alguém is
alguma pessoa). They are quantification in every POS. The negative
ones (ninguém, nada, nenhum) deny existence and are polarity
(§6.1). Personal, demonstrative, relative and interrogative pronouns stay
reference, and so does the indefinite article um (§6.3).
The same holds for indefinite place adverbs. Algures, alhures,
dalgures and dalhures ("somewhere", "elsewhere") quantify
existentially over places, as algo does over entities. They are
quantification, not reference: nothing is resolved against the
utterance situation, as it is for aqui or lĂĄ. The negative nenhures
is polarity.
polarity vs focus: who carries the negation? A negative scalar item
is polarity only if it carries the negation itself. Nem sequer, nem
mesmo, nem ao menos and tampouco (também não) do, so they are
polarity. Sequer alone needs a negation found elsewhere (nĂŁo
conseguiu [sequer] apresentar um plano), and adds only scalar "even" over
alternatives, like até and mesmo. It is focus.
Nem carries the negation itself in all its uses: as a negative
coordinator (nĂŁo come [nem] bebe, [nem] A [nem] B), as a standalone
negator ([nem] pensar) and as negative "even" ([nem] ele sabe). It is
polarity in every POS, and so is e nem. Coordination is the
construction it occurs in, not what the lemma encodes.
Exception and inclusion are focus. Exceto, salvo, tirante,
excluindo, com exceção de and incluindo remove members from, or add
members to, a set of alternatives, as exclusive sĂł and additive
inclusive do. They are focus in every POS. The conditional salvo se
and exceto se ("unless") are connection.
Prepositions are not a single case. ADP splits across both sorts:
contentful spatial and temporal adpositions are relation, governed
case-markers are predication, and some are polarity or connection
(§6.2).
modality vs value: does the lemma name a scale? Epistemic adverbs
with a lexicalized dimension are value, not modality. Provavelmente,
certamente, possivelmente and seguramente each name a region on the
probability/certainty dimension (probabilidade, certeza), have a gradable
adjectival counterpart (provĂĄvel, certo), and stand to it exactly as
belamente stands to beleza (§6.1). The following diagnostics help separate them from
modality:
| Test | value â provavelmente |
modality â talvez |
|---|---|---|
degree modification |
muito provavelmente â | *muito talvez â |
| lexicalized dimension and adjective | probabilidade, provĂĄvel â | none â |
| embeds under negation | nĂŁo Ă© provĂĄvel que⊠â | *nĂŁo talvez⊠â |
| governs mood | no | yes â subjunctive |
Degree modification supports a value analysis when it modifies a lexicalized
scale. It is not decisive alone: quotation, coercion and contextual readings
can alter acceptability. Talvez normally lacks this scalar behavior and can
license the subjunctive. Modal auxiliaries remain modality on their modal
readings. Use the diagnostics together with lexical meaning.
The tests apply to the head of a multiword expression. The certainty
MWEs com certeza, de certeza, por certo, ao certo and decerto
contain the dimension itself (certeza, certo). They are gradable through
their head (com toda certeza), even though *muito com certeza is
blocked by syntax. Like certamente, they name the top of the certainty
dimension, so they are value. The necessity adverbs necessariamente and
obrigatoriamente pass none of the tests (*muito necessariamente): they
express a modal force with no scale named, so they are modality.
The modal flavour is a fact about the occurrence, not the lemma. One
modal auxiliary is one modality lemma, whichever flavour it expresses:
epistemic ([deve] ter sido no meio do ano), deontic ([deve] ser
administrada por via oral), or ability and circumstantial possibility
(não [podendo] el-rei alcançar, quem se deslocar a pé [pode] chegar).
Following Kratzer, a modal contributes a quantificational force (dever
necessity, poder possibility), and the context supplies the kind of
modality. Splitting by flavour would fail §1.4's own criterion: the
flavours can be readings of one typed lemma rather than different lemma types.
They still require distinct LU/frame analyses where their meanings differ;
mixed deontic and epistemic annotations are not validated by a shared
modality type. The flavour is recorded in the frame the LU evokes: Capability,
Possibility, Required_event, Being_obligated, Likelihood, Expectation. A
modality lemma may carry these LUs like any other lemma (§8).
What splits off is a reading that is not modal at all, under §1.4:
dever-se a "be due to" and dever "owe" require conceptual analysis
of causation/dependency or indebtedness; do not assign event merely because
the forms are verbs or occur in Commerce-related frames; the nouns o poder (power: Objective_influence,
Electricity, the Poderes of the state) and o dever (duty, deveres)
are separate NOUN lemmas.
Optatives are modality. OxalĂĄ, tomara, Deus queira and quem
me dera express the speaker's wish about the proposition: bouletic
modality, with no scale named. Like talvez, they govern the subjunctive
([tomara] que chova). They are modality in every POS, INTJ included.
They do not manage the exchange, so they are not interaction.
The copula and support verbs are predication. They instruct how to
assemble a predication and contribute no concept of their own. This does
not prevent them from having LUs (§6.2, "Not an LU target").
Aspect: phase verbs are event, aspect auxiliaries are predication.
The line does not depend on whether the verb heads a periphrasis. It depends
on whether the verb names a phase of an event.
- Phase verbs name the start, continuation, end, interruption or
resumption of an event, or its habituality: começar, iniciar,
continuar, prosseguir, acabar, terminar, parar, deixar de,
passar a, voltar a, costumar. These phase/habitual readings are typed
event, whether realized with nominal or verbal complements; this does not classify every other reading of the same forms. They evoke the phase frames (Activity_start, Activity_ongoing, Activity_finish, Activity_stop, Process_resume, Custom, âŠ) exactly as iniciar or interromper do. Começou a reuniĂŁo and começou a chover are oneeventlemma, and two LUs only if the frames differ. - Aspect and tense auxiliaries mark the event without naming a phase:
estar / andar / vir + gerund (progressive; vem melhorando), ir + infinitive (future),
ter / haver + participle (perfect), estar prestes a (prospective).
They are
predication. An LU annotated on such an auxiliary â the progressive estar in Activity_ongoing â stays on thepredicationlemma.
Two supporting diagnostics for the phase-versus-auxiliary distinction:
| Test | phase verb â começar | auxiliary â progressive estar |
|---|---|---|
| takes a nominal complement with the same meaning | começou a reuniĂŁo â | estar + NP has no progressive reading â |
| a lexical verb with the same phase meaning can replace it | começou a reuniĂŁo â iniciou a reuniĂŁo â | no lexical verb means "in progress" â |
A verb with both uses splits under §1.4 only if both readings carry LUs.
Ficar in "[ficou] trĂȘs dias internado" or "nada [fica] na mesma" means
remain (State_continue, event). In "[ficava] voando" it means keep
doing, a phase (Activity_ongoing, also event). In "ficou rico" it is the
inchoative event reading. The predication ficar keeps only its
copular-stative LUs.
interaction is about the exchange, not the proposition. It covers
interjections (ué, nossa, ai), interactional and tag particles (né,
hein, viu, tĂĄ), attention markers (olha, escuta), hedges and
approximators (tipo, assim), and quotative or evidential markers (diz
que, dizem que) â whatever manages the interaction rather than
contributing to or operating on the proposition expressed.
Three boundaries:
- vs
connection. A connective relates two propositions inferentially (portanto, contudo); an interactional particle relates the utterance to the hearer (né seeks confirmation, viu secures uptake). Test: does removing it leave an inferential gap between two units, or only a blunter utterance? - vs
modality.modalitymarks the speaker's own commitment to the proposition (talvez, poder); evidentials mark where the information came from (diz que, supostamente, alegadamente, pretensamente, aparentemente, presumivelmente). FNBr keeps evidentials ininteractionbecause they invoke the hearer's assessment of the source rather than stating the speaker's confidence (Appendix §A.7). That holds for reportative and inferential evidentials alike, as clitic, verb phrase or adverb (parece que, pelo visto, ao que parece). Attribution of source or perspective by a preposition works the same way: segundo ("according to") and para in [para] a Dinamarca, era bom⊠("in X's view") areinteraction. De acordo com, conforme and consoante split under §1.4. Their source reading ([de acordo com] a polĂcia) isinteraction. Their conformity reading ([de acordo com] a lei, "in accordance with") names a relation of correspondence and isrelation. Clausal conforme ([conforme] ele disse, [conforme] o tempo passa) staysconnection. - vs
focus. Só, até, mesmo operate on the proposition's information structure and arefocus. Tipo and assim as hedges signal approximation in the exchange rather than restructuring the proposition.
Three more cases sit on these boundaries:
- The verb parecer. Copular parecer (parece cansado) is not a bare
copula: it adds the appearance the predication rests on. It stays
event. The evidential parece que isinteraction. - Speech-act adverbs (francamente, sinceramente, honestamente).
In sentence-initial use ([Francamente], nĂŁo sei) they comment on the
speech act, not on the proposition, so they are
interaction. Their manner reading (falou francamente) is avalue, like any manner adverb. When both readings carry LUs, the lemma splits under §1.4. - Confirmation adverbs. De fato, realmente, efetivamente,
verdadeiramente and deveras mark verum focus: they put the truth
of the proposition in focus (eles, [de fato], sĂŁo o povo mais feliz),
so they are
focus. Na verdade and na realidade introduce a correction or reformulation of a previous unit (não é X; na verdade, é Y), so they areconnection. Before an adjective, realmente and deveras are intensifiers ([deveras] abstratas), which isdegree. That reading splits off under §1.4 when it carries LUs.
interaction lemmas evoke pragmatic frames like any other lemma.
6. Parts of speech the type layer cuts across#
Some UPOS tags collect lemmas with almost nothing semantically in common. The
type layer is expected to cut across them; ADV, ADP and NUM need
worked guidance.
Three POS sit at the edge of the type layer:
PROPNlemmas are typed by what they name. Institutions, places, peoples, people and brands areobject(UFJF, Ibitipoca, Cemig); an event isevent(a festival). An acronym of a common noun is not a proper name: PIB, CPF and PEC areNOUN, typed like the noun they abbreviate.PUNCTandSYMlemmas carry no type. They encode neither a concept nor a processing instruction about the proposition, so the two-sort vocabulary of §2 does not apply.- Digits, times, percentages and roman numerals (18, 18h, 15%,
XVIII) are
NUMlemmas andvalue, like the numerals of §6.3. Written ordinals (1Âș, 15ÂȘ) areADJandvalue.
6.1 Adverbs#
"Adverb" is a part-of-speech wastebasket, not a semantic class â it collects manner, place, time, frequency, degree, epistemic and connective words with almost nothing in common. Under the two-sort vocabulary, the class splits cleanly, with most members turning out to be procedural.
| Adverb class | Encodes | Type |
|---|---|---|
| Manner (belamente, rapidamente) | a region on a quality dimension, predicated of an event | value |
| Time extent (recentemente) | a region on a temporal-distance dimension | value |
| Frequency, graded (raramente, frequentemente, ocasionalmente, regularmente) | a region on the frequency dimension | value |
| Degree / intensity (muito, pouco, bastante) | locate a value against a standard | degree |
| Universal frequency (sempre, diariamente, o tempo todo) | universal quantification over times or occasions | quantification |
| Generic frequency (geralmente, normalmente, usualmente, habitualmente, em geral) | generic quantification over occasions | quantification |
| Existential frequency (Ă s vezes, por vezes, de vez em quando, volta e meia) | existential quantification over occasions | quantification |
| Phasal (ainda, jĂĄ) | quantification over the phases of a state, relative to a reference time | quantification |
| Epistemic, scalar (provavelmente, certamente, possivelmente, com certeza, obviamente) | a region on the probability/certainty dimension | value |
| Epistemic, non-scalar (talvez) | epistemic status, no scale named; governs subjunctive | modality |
| Necessity (necessariamente, obrigatoriamente) | modal force, no scale named | modality |
| Evidential (supostamente, alegadamente, aparentemente, pelo visto, ao que parece) | source of the information | interaction |
| Speech-act (francamente, sinceramente, honestamente), sentence-initial | comment on the speech act | interaction |
| Confirmation (de fato, realmente, efetivamente) | verum focus | focus |
| Reformulation (na verdade, na realidade) | correction of a previous unit | connection |
| Epistemic stance as a concept (dĂșvida, incerteza, certeza) | the dimension itself | quality |
| Place and deictic time (aqui, hoje, agora) | resolution instruction | reference |
| Time of day, anchored time (de manhĂŁ, Ă noite, de noite, mais tarde, com o tempo) | temporal location of the event, nothing resolved against the utterance | relation |
| Conjunctive (contudo, portanto) | discourse relation | connection |
| Affirmation / negation (sim, nĂŁo, nunca, nada, nenhum) | polarity | polarity |
Manner adverbs are values, not dimensions. Belamente stands to beleza exactly as bonito does â a region on the same dimension, predicated of an event rather than an entity. What the value is predicated of is a frame-level fact, not a type-level one.
Deictics are procedural, not relations. Aqui and hoje encode an
instruction to resolve a referent against the utterance situation â the
textbook case of procedural encoding. Their image-schematic character is
carried by what their frames ground in (FIGURE_GROUND, DEICTIC).
Zero is polarity, not a low value. Nada and nenhum look like values on
the quantity dimension, parallel to pouco. But a low value presupposes
existence â pouco asserts some quantity, just a small one â while nada
and nenhum deny existence outright (ÂŹâx). The same line separates
raramente (a low but positive frequency, still asserting the event
occurred) from nunca (a negative existential over time points). A zero
reading on any dimension negates that dimension's existential presupposition
rather than measuring a small amount of it. Nada is polarity.
Frequency adverbs require both scope and degree diagnostics. Their types cannot be read from a shared frame name. Use §5's diagnostics alongside the quantificational or scalar meaning; a Frequency allocation is not automatic approval of every candidate reading.
- Gradable (muito frequentemente, muito raramente, muito
ocasionalmente, muito regularmente â): these name a region on the
frequency dimension, the counterpart of frequente, raro or regular,
and are
value. - Not gradable (*muito sempre, *muito geralmente, *muito Ă s
vezes, *muito diariamente â): these quantify over occasions, in the
sense of Lewis's adverbs of quantification, and are
quantification. The force is universal (sempre, diariamente, o tempo todo), generic (geralmente, normalmente, usualmente, habitualmente, tipicamente, em geral) or existential (Ă s vezes, por vezes, de vez em quando, volta e meia). - Zero frequency (nunca) stays
polarity, by the rule above.
The type follows the frequency reading only. Normalmente also has a manner
reading (as pessoas trabalham normalmente, "in the normal way"), which is
value. When both readings carry LUs, §1.4 splits the lemma.
The polarity relation is not the act. NĂŁo as propositional polarity is
polarity; the act of affirming or denying (afirmar, negar) is an
event in an @agentive frame. Negação carries both readings under one
form and one POS, and is split into two lemmas accordingly (§1.4).
6.2 Prepositions and adpositions#
ADP is one UPOS covering lemmas on both sides of the conceptual/procedural
line; the split does not follow the tag at all. A preposition may name a
relation, mark a case, express polarity or carry a discourse connection.
| Use | Examples | Type |
|---|---|---|
| Spatial or temporal configuration | sobre, sob, entre, contra, durante, apĂłs, dentro de, ao lado de, antes de | relation |
| Topic | sobre, a respeito de, acerca de, quanto a, em relação a, com relação a ("um livro sobre linguĂstica", "sobre as fake news, âŠ") | relation |
| Means or route | por ("por via oral", "pela estrada"), em ("fala em inglĂȘs"), atravĂ©s de | relation |
| Having or wearing | com ("mulher com blusa rosa") | relation |
| Privative | sem | polarity |
| Causal, concessive, conditional | por causa de, apesar de, devido a, em vez de, causal por (preso por roubo) | connection |
| Conformity | de acordo com, conforme, consoante ("de acordo com a lei") | relation |
| Exception, inclusion | exceto, salvo, tirante, excluindo, incluindo, com exceção de | focus |
| Source or perspective | segundo, de acordo com, conforme, consoante ("de acordo com a polĂcia"), para ("para mim", "para a Dinamarca") | interaction |
| Marking an FE that a head selects | de in gostar de, a in obedecer a, em in acreditar em, com in contar com, de in orgulhoso de | predication |
| Marking an FE that the head's frame supplies | por (passive agent), com (instrument), para (beneficiary), de in pai de JoĂŁo and o retrato de JoĂŁo | predication |
| Anchoring an N de N construction | de with a sortal head: mesa de madeira, o carro de JoĂŁo, measure um copo de ĂĄgua | predication |
The last three rows are the case-marking uses. Portuguese nouns have no case morphology. In Latin or Finnish, case affixes signal how a noun phrase relates to the word it depends on. In Portuguese, prepositions do that job.
What a case-marking preposition contributes. Three claims about such a preposition must be kept apart:
| Claim | Holds? |
|---|---|
| (a) the use is not an LU target | yes: an LU would duplicate the head's valence |
| (b) the preposition evokes no frame of its own | yes: the frame belongs to the head or to a construction |
| (c) the preposition contributes no meaning | no |
Neither (a) nor (b) entails (c). Doing the job of case does not make a form empty: Jakobson's analysis of the Russian cases (1936) gives every case a general meaning. FNBr takes a schematic view. De has one underspecified meaning, roughly "intrinsic association or dependency", historically derived from source â partitive â genitive (compare Langacker 1992 on English of). The specific relation (possession, material, measure, authorship) is not stored in de. It comes from the head's frame, from a construction, or from pragmatic enrichment.
Two alternatives are rejected. Vacuity (de means nothing) is contradicted by the data below. Polysemy (one sense, and one LU, per relation) would copy the FE inventory of every head frame into the preposition, although the readings are predictable from head and complement.
The evidence. Vary one side at a time.
- Hold de fixed and vary the nouns. Mesa de madeira (material), mesa de JoĂŁo (possession), mesa de jantar (purpose), mesa de dois metros (measure): the relation tracks the nouns, so it is not stored in de. O retrato de JoĂŁo is ambiguous between JoĂŁo as painter, as the person depicted and as owner. De is compatible with all three, and each is an FE of the head's frame.
- Hold the nouns fixed and vary the preposition. Mesa de madeira â mesa em madeira shows no truth-conditional difference. But copo de ĂĄgua allows the measure reading ("a glassful"), while copo com ĂĄgua forces container plus contents. De is doing something there, even if part of the measure reading belongs to the polysemy of copo.
Four kinds of prepositional contribution.
| Kind | Example | Who evokes the frame | Where the preposition is recorded | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Frame-evoking | sobre/sob a mesa, durante, apĂłs, topic sobre, means por, mulher com blusa | the preposition | its own LU, with the frame's FEs | relation |
| B. Head-selected | gostar de, acreditar em, contar com, orgulhoso de | the head | the head's valence: phrase type PP[de] | predication |
| C. Frame-supplied | passive por, instrument com, beneficiary para; pai de JoĂŁo, o retrato de JoĂŁo | the head, whose frame has the FE | the head's valence; the FE assignment resolves any ambiguity | predication |
| D. Constructional anchor | mesa de madeira, o carro de JoĂŁo, measure um copo de ĂĄgua | an N de N construction | the construction, as its construction-evoking element | predication |
- A. The preposition names the relation. Replacing sobre with sob changes what is said, so this use is not case-marking. Topic sobre, means por and the com of having belong here too. The PP answers a question with the preposition inside it (Sobre o quĂȘ?, Por onde?, Com que roupa?), and it can stand with no head that selects it (Sobre as fake news, respondaâŠ).
- B. The choice of preposition is a lexical fact about the head. Using another one gives an ungrammatical string, not a different meaning (*gostar em mĂșsica). What the position means (what is liked, who is obeyed) is an FE of the head's frame. The choice is often motivated (acreditar em and pensar em construe the content as a location), but that motivation is systemic, not something a single token predicts.
- C. No single head selects the preposition: any passive verb takes por. The role the PP fills already belongs to the head's frame, and the preposition picks it out or allows it.
- D. The head noun's frame has no FE for the relation, so the relation
comes from a construction. FrameNet's constructicon (Fillmore,
Lee-Goldman & Rhomieux 2012) lets a construction evoke a frame, with a
lexically fixed construction-evoking element. In FNBr, frames evoked
by constructions are recorded with
rel_evokes. In N de N, de is that element: it carries meaning as the fixed anchor of a meaningful construction, without being an LU.
Telling C from D. Does the head noun's frame already have an FE that the de-phrase fills?
- Yes â C. Retrato has Creator and Depicted; pai has its relatum; a deverbal noun has its event's FEs.
- No â D. The relation must come from a construction.
Partee & Borschev's analysis of the genitive draws the same line. With a relational head (pai de João), the head supplies the relation and the genitive marks its argument. With a sortal head (o carro de João), the construction introduces a free relation R, resolved by context or by the head's qualia (Vikner & Jensen 2002). Adding peripheral FEs such as Material or Possessor to every artifact frame would turn D into C, but it repeats the same FEs in every sortal frame. The construction states the generalization once. Which option FNBr adopts is open (§A.9).
Diagnostics for kind B. The three diagnostics below separate kind A from kind B: a preposition that names a relation from one that a head selects. They do not apply to the nominal uses. De quem Ă© o carro? â De JoĂŁo passes questionability. Copo de/com ĂĄgua passes contrastive substitution while mesa de/em madeira fails it. A sortal head like mesa lists no de in its valence, so government does not apply. For nominal uses, use the C/D test above.
- Contrastive substitution. Holding the governing head constant, can
another preposition replace it with a truth-conditional difference? O
livro estĂĄ sobre / sob a mesa â yes, so
relation. *Gostar em â no, sopredication. - Questionability. Can the PP answer a wh-question with the preposition inside the answer? Onde? â Sobre a mesa. Governed prepositions fail â there is no question whose answer is de in gostar de.
- Government. Is the preposition listed in the valence of the head that
selects it? If yes,
predicationregardless of what it means elsewhere.
Diagnostic 3 overrides the other two when they conflict: government is observable in the valence data, while the other two rest on judgement.
Not an LU target, which is not the same as contributing nothing. Three points follow from the four kinds.
- A case-marking use is not an LU. In gostar de mĂșsica, the frame is
evoked by gostar. De mĂșsica is annotated as an FE of that frame, with
de as part of its phrase type (PP[de]). The preposition is recorded in
the head's valence pattern as the marker of that position, the role
synsem:markerplays in OntoLex-Lemon. An LU for de in gostar's frame, or in some "genitive" frame, would record the same valence fact twice and treat a schematic contribution as a frame of its own. - In kind D, the frame belongs to the construction. De anchors the N de N construction that evokes it, and is not an LU of that frame.
- The
predicationtype does not forbid LUs. The type says the lemma contributes no concept of its own that the head, the frame or a construction does not already supply. It does not say the lemma is meaningless, nor that it can never be a frame target. §8 holds for this type as for every other. Some readings ofpredicationlemmas are annotated as targets and carry LUs: the progressive estar in Activity_ongoing, and copular-stative ficar and estar in State frames (§5).
So "not an LU" describes a use (kinds B, C and D), not a type. Copulas and support verbs work the same way. In their ordinary use they assemble a predication around a noun or adjective that evokes the frame. They have LUs only where a reading of their own is annotated as a target.
An existing LU on a predication lemma is therefore something to review
case by case, not an error in itself. If the LU annotates a kind B or C use
(the FE's preposition annotated as if it were the target), it duplicates
valence. If it annotates a kind D use, the frame belongs to the
construction. If it annotates a reading that is itself a frame target, it
stands.
Outcome of the 2026 review. The LUs on predication prepositions were
reviewed against these rules. Em in Using and Separating and instrument
com in Using repeated the head's valence and were retired. Com in Wearing,
por and em in Means and the topic LUs name a relation of their own and
moved to relation lemmas. De in Partitive, Possession and Type moved to the
complex lemma $n_de_n, which stands in for the N de N construction
(§A.9, item 14). Partitive sets whose head noun evokes a frame of its own
(inĂcio, metade, maioria, the body parts) went to the head's LU or were
dropped as duplicates of it.
Annotating N de N. A complex lemma with an LU gets a span on the annotation page under the words it covers (ADR 0008). Clicking the span offers its LUs. The target is de alone, as in the sets moved in 2026: tick de and untick the span in the span bar. The two nouns carry the frame's FEs.
The pattern of $n_de_n is
({NOUN} | {PROPN} | {NUM} | {PRON}) [{ADV}] [{ADJ}] [{ADJ}] {=de} [{$quant}] [({$art} | {$dem} | {$poss_det})] [{$num}] [{ADV}] [{ADJ}] ({NOUN} | {PROPN})
{=de} also matches the contractions (do, da, dos, das), which are forms
of de. The head side allows um dos, algumas das and post-nominal
adjectives (pontos fortes do). Tested in November 2026 on the 128 sets of
the three LUs, it covered 117 of them. It misses coordination (da PM e da
prefeitura), a comma between the nouns, and an N de N with no head noun
(dos 36 clubes, 11âŠ). It also matches names such as Copa do Mundo and
Rio Grande do Norte, which have lemmas of their own.
What the preposition itself construes in kinds B and C is not recorded today. A per-annotation label for it, alongside the FE, is an open proposal (§A.9).
Applying the rule. Adpositions illustrate §1.4's one-type-per-lemma
principle. Split only when type divergence is established within the lexical
identity. Splitting stays bounded because readings that
share a type do not split: de has at least six distinguishable readings but
only two types in the analyses below. All the case-marking uses of a
preposition (kinds B, C and D) are uses of its one predication lemma.
It is the same lemma with the same schematic contribution in every case;
the specific relation is evoked by the head or by the N de N
construction. None of these uses needs an LU. Splitting the nominal uses
off as a relation lemma with an underspecified relation is not adopted:
it would add splits (§A.9, item 7) for a generalization the construction
already states.
| Lemma | Type | Covers | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
deâ |
predication |
head-selected (B); genitive with a relational head (C); material, possession and measure with a sortal head (D) | gostar de mĂșsica; o pai de JoĂŁo; mesa de madeira; o carro de JoĂŁo; um copo de ĂĄgua |
deâ |
relation |
source and origin, spatial or temporal | veio de SĂŁo Paulo; de segunda a sexta |
aâ |
predication |
government; dative and recipient marking | obedecer a uma ordem; dei o livro a JoĂŁo |
aâ |
relation |
goal, direction, temporal location | fui a Roma; Ă s trĂȘs horas |
emâ |
predication |
government | acreditar em algo; pensar em vocĂȘ |
emâ |
relation |
containment, location, temporal location, means | na mesa; em 2020; no Brasil; fala em inglĂȘs |
porâ |
predication |
passive agent; government; price marking | destruĂdo por JoĂŁo; optar por outro; comprei por dez reais |
porâ |
relation |
path, duration, means, stance | passou por SĂŁo Paulo; por trĂȘs horas; por via oral; manifestação por melhorias |
porâ |
connection |
cause, linking an event to its cause | preso por roubo; nĂŁo veio por estar doente |
comâ |
predication |
government; instrument and manner marking | contar com vocĂȘ; cortou com a faca; com cuidado |
comâ |
relation |
comitative, accompaniment, having or wearing | foi com Maria; café com leite; mulher com blusa rosa |
paraâ |
predication |
government; beneficiary and recipient marking | olhar para a janela; comprei um livro para JoĂŁo |
paraâ |
relation |
goal, direction | fui para Roma; para o norte |
paraâ |
connection |
purpose, linking two events | saiu para comprar pĂŁo |
paraâ |
interaction |
perspective ("in X's view") | para a Dinamarca, era bom⊠|
sobre |
relation |
superposition and topic â no split, both readings have one type | o livro estĂĄ sobre a mesa; um livro sobre linguĂstica |
semâ |
polarity |
privative â no split, one type covers every reading | sem açĂșcar; saiu sem pagar |
Sobre and sem do not split. Sobre has two readings, superposition and
topic, each with its own LU, but both are relation. The split is driven by
type divergence and nothing else.
Contractions are forms, not lemmas. Do, ao, pelo, no, num,
dum, pro and coa fuse a preposition with an article. UD splits the
token into its two words, and the article is a form of o or um
(reference). The preposition part is a form of the preposition's
lemmas: do/da/dos/das belong to deâ and deâ, ao/Ă /aos/Ă s to aâ
and aâ, pelo/pela to porââporâ, no/na/num/numa to emâ and
emâ. Contractions get no lemmas of their own, so the split covers them
without being repeated.
Disambiguation. Splitting means UPOS filters nothing between deâ and
deâ â they share both text and POS. Disambiguation comes from the syntactic
context, using evidence already in the UD parse:
- Government. If the adposition's head is a predicate that selects it â
the
casedependent of anobl/objwhose head lists that preposition in its valence â this supports thepredicationreading. Parser and valence evidence remain defeasible; preserve alternatives where government is uncertain. - Complement semantics. A place or time complement favours the
relationlemma; an infinitival complement under para forcesparaâ. - Unresolved. Where the evidence does not distinguish the candidates, preserve the candidate set and record uncertainty. Frequency or an assumed lower cost of deleting conceptual content is not semantic disambiguation.
Extended discussion of the accuracy trade-off this moves to the parser is in Appendix §A.8.
Nothing here is specific to adpositions â the same rule produces
negaçãoâ/negaçãoâ and pinturaâ/pinturaâ in the content lexicon
(§1.4). Adpositions are simply where it fires most often: a small set of very
frequent forms each span the conceptual/procedural line. The split count is
concentrated â a handful of function words account for most of it.
Complex prepositions are MWE lemmas tagged ADP. Dentro de, ao lado
de, por causa de, apesar de take entry_type = mwe and pos = ADP, an
exception to the X convention for MWE entries (§1.2). A multiword
expression that takes no complement (daqui em diante, em pleno ar) is
an adverb, ADV. Their type follows the table above and is often
connection rather than relation, which is a further reason not to read
the type off the tag.
The type cuts across ADP/SCONJ as well as within ADP. Por causa de
(ADP) and porque (SCONJ) are both connection; para + infinitive sits
on the boundary â the tag predicts the type in neither direction.
Consequence for participant structure. Review participant associations where appropriate role lexicalizations exist. A spatial or temporal relation does not require a Portuguese noun for every FE. Missing lexicalization is not a type error, and role definition does not require the participant LU to evoke the relation frame.
6.3 Numerals and proportional nouns#
NUM looks quantificational, since dois livros behaves like alguns
livros, but the type follows what the lemma names.
| Class | Examples | Type |
|---|---|---|
| Cardinal numeral | um, dois, cem, mil, milhĂŁo (NUM) |
value |
| Ordinal numeral | primeiro, quarto, décimo | value |
| Collective numeral noun | dezena, dĂșzia, centena, milhar, milhĂŁo, bilhĂŁo (NOUN) |
value |
| Dual quantifier | ambos (every POS) | quantification |
| Proportional noun | maioria, minoria, metade, parte, totalidade, resto, porção | role |
Numerals name a point. A cardinal names a point on the number dimension
and an ordinal a point on an ordering. Both are nameable without a bearer
(dois Ă© par, o primeiro chegou), and both evoke Cardinal_numbers or
Ordinal_numbers as concepts. They are value, like any region or point.
The determiner-like use (dois livros) is a construal of that value by the
Num + N construction, not a second type. The collective nouns name the same
points (uma dezena is 10) and are value too.
ambos is a quantifier, not a number. It has no number-name use
(*o ambos, *ambos Ă© par). It quantifies universally over a domain of
two, so it is quantification in every POS, NUM included.
Zero. Zero as a numeral names the point 0 and stays value. "Zero is
polarity" (§6.1) concerns nada and nenhum, which deny existence; zero
measures it.
Units and time intervals are value. A unit of measure names a fixed
magnitude on a dimension: metro, litro, quilo, caloria, polegada, currency
units (dĂłlar, real, centavo) and measure nouns (pitada, colherada,
punhado). Dois quilos is a numeral plus a value, as dois livros is a
numeral plus an object. Calendar and clock nouns name a stretch of the time
line (dul:TimeInterval â dul:Region): janeiro, segunda-feira, dia,
semana, manhã, verão, século, prazo. So do dates and holidays (feriado,
Natal, aniversĂĄrio). A noun that names the celebration itself, as
carnaval does, is event.
Proportional nouns are role. A half, a majority or a remainder cannot
exist without a whole that is not part of it, and that is §3's external
dependence test. Metade stands to its whole as filho stands to its
parent. Their quantifier-like use (a maioria dos alunos, metade do
bolo) is the partitive construction, recorded at the frame and
construction layers, not by the lemma type.
7. Why coarse: the three layers#
The asymmetry is the most important property of this design; with the type on the lemma it reads as three layers:
| Layer | Grain | Carries |
|---|---|---|
| lemma | coarse identity | the type â what kind of thing the lexeme names |
| LU | sense | the lemmaâframe pairing and a sense description â no type |
| frame | situation | the namespace, the participant structure, the grounding schema |
- An
eventlemma can have causative and inchoative readings in different frames without requiring a type split. A proposed resulting-condition reading still needs semantic evidence; the lemma's type neither validates nor rules out a State allocation (§8). - Aquecer is one lemma typed
event, with LUs inCausar_mudança_de_temperaturaandMudança_de_temperatura. Same type, different frames â the ordinary case. valuebehaves the same way across@attribute,@state,@entity,@experientialand (as adjectives and adverbs)@relation. Americano names a region on the origem dimension, full stop, regardless of what it is predicated of: a person (um americano), a thing (um carro americano) or an event (o ataque americano).frm_people_by_originis an@entityframe built overvaluelemmas, and it is not an exception â the same analysis can be evaluated for other participant-category frames. A frame's name or current type distribution does not establish this analysis for all its LUs. For a supported construal shift (§1.4), the lemma staysvalueand the referent varies with what the construction supplies.- POS differences split the lemma, not the LU. Dependenteâ ("meu
dependente") is
role; dependenteâ ("ele Ă© dependente") isvalueâ two lemmas by §1.2, each with its own type and its own LUs. Unlike americano above, this is not a construal shift: the noun names a fixed institutional role, not "person" as a default referent for the value (§1.4). - Type divergence splits the lemma too. Where one form under one POS carries two types, it is two lemmas by §1.4. Nothing in the LU table records a type, so no divergence can be hidden there.
Construal shifts change neither. Ele Ă© pai shifts a functional concept
to a sortal predicate without changing the underlying concept (Löbner); o
bonito and um americano refer to an entity a value lemma characterizes
without becoming sortals themselves. Neither automatically establishes type ambiguity or requires a lemma split.
Whether a distinct LU is needed depends on the established reading and frame,
not on the presence of an NP construction alone. §1.4 has the general statement and the diagnostic that tells a
construal shift apart from a genuine split like dependenteâ/dependenteâ
above.
8. Lemma type and LU allocation#
The lemma type does not restrict which frames a lemma's LUs may evoke. A
frame describes a situation, and one situation can be evoked by lemmas of
diverse types: an event verb naming the happening, a role noun naming a
participant, a value adjective naming a condition, a quality or relation
noun naming a dimension or tie. No namespace Ă type compatibility matrix
("admit-set") is defined, and no combination of lemma type and frame
namespace is an error by itself.
The namespace Ă type matrix proposed in Phase 2 of the structural repair (2026-10-14) is withdrawn as allocation policy. Its outcomes (PASS, CONDITIONAL, FAIL, EXEMPT, NO_RULE) carry no documentation authority and must not be used as review verdicts.
Type and namespace answer different questions. The type says what kind of concept, or processing instruction, the lemma encodes (§3, §5); the namespace says what kind of situation the frame describes (Frames). An LU's allocation is judged by its reading against the frame's definition and participant structure, not by its lemma's type.
Specific evaluations#
Particular combinations may later be checked by targeted evaluations, each with its own explicitly stated rule and rationale. The expected first case is FNBr's agentive-name policy: agentive nouns (trabalhador, comprador) with LUs in eventive frames are candidates for moving to Entity frames, with their participation recorded as an association (see below). A targeted evaluation produces a review list, not automatic moves, retyping or merges.
The second case, decided 2026-11-11, is the value adjectives in eventive
frames. An adjective stays in the event frame when its reading evokes the
event with its participants, so that the noun it modifies fills an FE of the
event (arma letal, doença curåvel). A relational adjective that sorts the
noun by domain (material escolar, exame médico) is Attribute.Classifying,
in Domain. See Property adjectives and event
frames.
What the type layer checks on its own#
Independently of frames, a lemma's type can be checked against the criteria of this document:
- POS consistency: lexical verbs are
event, except copulas, auxiliaries and support verbs (predication) and modal auxiliaries (modality) (§5). - Deverbal nouns are
eventunless they have a product sense (§4), so a deverbal noun typedqualityorobject(crescimento, asfixia, batismo) is a typing candidate. - Externally dependent nouns are
role(§4), so relational nouns typedobject(avÎ, metade) are typing candidates. - Dimensions are
qualityand regions arevalue(§4). - Untyped lemmas require a type; punctuation and symbols take none (§6).
These are checks on the type assignment, not on LU allocation.
Participant structure#
Where a relation or event has suitable participant lexicalizations, review their
association with the relevant FEs. Role definition (isDefinedIn) and a
participant LU's lexicalization home are separate facts. Roles outside
Relation frames are not automatically errors. FNBr places agentive names in
Entity frames and associates them with the event FE separately.
Use FEâFrame associations only if all relevant LUs of the Entity frame qualify; otherwise use LUâFE associations for the subset. Resolve nested CON expressions before reporting a missing association. Absence of a role noun for a spatial or temporal FE does not invalidate that relation. See FrameNet patterns.
Review outcomes#
Multiple namespaces under a lemma are normal when distinct readings justify them; namespace diversity alone is not a split criterion.
- A wrong sense is not detected by the lemma's type: ser.v in Artes_cĂȘnicas, receber.v in a sports-move frame and torcer.v in Dar_forma need semantic review of the reading, whatever the type.
- Within-class distinctions such as Agentive versus Change require semantic review.
- Missing glosses, duplicate-looking records and attached annotations require separate evidence review; none establishes correctness or equivalence alone.
- No check automatically assigns types, splits lemmas, moves LUs or merges records. Apply only approved, evidence-backed changes.
Appendix#
Secondary material: full definitions, theoretical provenance, extended diagnostics, design notes, and open questions. None of it is required to classify a lemma, but §A.1 underlies the criteria in §3.
A.1 Definitions#
Six notions from formal ontology and lexical semantics, used by the diagnostics throughout this document and by the criteria in §3.
Rigidity (Guarino & Welty, OntoClean). A property is rigid if essential to all its instances: anything that is P must be P for as long as it exists (pessoa, cadeira). It is anti-rigid if every instance could cease to be P and survive (comprador, criança, cansado), and semi-rigid if essential for some instances and accidental for others. Anti-rigid properties cannot subsume rigid ones â why pessoa is not a kind of agente. Rigidity is defined here but is not a typing axis (§A.2).
Identity and sortality. A property supplies identity if it carries a
criterion for saying "the same one again"; such properties are sortals,
answering what something is. Pessoa supplies identity; comprador
inherits it from pessoa; vermelho has none. Every object instantiates
exactly one identity-supplying kind. Both object and role are sortals
(§3); what separates them is external dependence, not sortality.
Unity. A property carries unity if all its instances are wholes under one unifying relation (functional, topological, morphological, intentional). Pessoa carries functional unity; ĂĄgua is anti-unity â an arbitrary sub-portion of water is still water. FNBr does not type on unity; it explains why mass nouns need no separate type (§A.3).
External dependence. A property is externally dependent (+D) if every
instance requires the existence of some entity y that is not a part or
constituent of it. Comprador requires a purchase and a seller; filho
requires a parent; cadeira requires nothing. This is the diagnostic that
separates object from role (§3, §4).
Relationality and uniqueness (Löbner, "Concept Types and Determination", Journal of Semantics 28(3), 2011). A noun concept is relational [+R] if it has an inherent argument slot for a relatum (irmĂŁ, filho), and unique [+U] if it determines at most one referent, absolutely or relative to its relatum (sol; pai relative to a child). Crossing the two yields sortal [âRâU], individual [âR+U], relational [+RâU] and functional [+R+U] concepts. FNBr does not type on [U], but both features supply corpus- observable diagnostics (§4) where the ontological test is hard to apply.
Dimension and region (GĂ€rdenfors, Conceptual Spaces; The Geometry of
Meaning). A quality is a dimension â an axis if gradable, a class if
categorial. A region is a value the dimension can take. Temperatura is
a dimension; quente is a region within it â the distinction underlying
quality vs value (§3, §4).
A.2 Why rigidity is not a typing axis#
Rigidity (§A.1) is not used to type anything. Anti-rigid intrinsic
sortals â criança, adulto, novato, defunto, concepts an individual
can stop falling under while continuing to exist, with no second entity
required â are typed object, the same as rigid sortals like pessoa.
The reason is annotator reliability. The dependence test (§4) asks a single existence question: is there some entity, not a part of this one, that must exist? Rigidity asks a modal question: could this individual cease to fall under this concept and still exist? Modal judgements of that kind can be unreliable for annotation, so rigidity is not a typing axis. Causal origin is likewise not a separate lemma-type axis (§A.5).
Consistent with DUL. dul:Concept â dul:SocialObject â dul:Object, so
an anti-rigid intrinsic sortal falls under dul:Object whether or not it is
named separately â a loss of specificity, not an error. It also repairs
role: under a single dependence test, filho is unproblematic even though
being someone's son is arguably rigid (you do not stop being your father's
son when he dies) yet plainly externally dependent.
What is lost. Criança and pessoa carry the same type despite differing
in rigidity, and an export to a rigidity-aware ontology (UFO, gUFO) would
have to decide Kind vs Phase at export time rather than reading it off
the stored type. If that export becomes a requirement, a dedicated phase
refinement would require explicit approval for anti-rigid intrinsic sortals, preserving
the coarse meaning of object assignments â a candidate list could be generated by
querying object lemmas whose frames are @entity frames built over
life-stage, career-stage or status dimensions.
A.3 No abstract type#
Abstract nouns need no type of their own. DUL's Abstract is not "abstract
nouns" â it is value spaces: Region, TimeInterval, SpaceRegion, the
space of natural numbers. dul:Object already covers social and cognitive
entities (SocialObject, InformationObject, Concept, Description), so
lei, ideia, teoria, poema are Objects in DUL already.
Fact, proposition and modal nouns require reading-level review. Do not type
a possibilidade as event merely because it concerns a possible situation;
a probability/possibility dimension may instead be quality. Its frame and
lemma type answer different questions.
Mass nouns need no separate type either: ågua is anti-unity but a rigid sortal, and unity is not a typing axis (§A.1).
Dot objects (livro = physical âą information) are deferred: if
co-predication comes to require it, add a boolean refinement on object â
physical vs social-informational â not a base type (see also §A.9, item 4).
A.4 Grimshaw's nominal diagnostics#
Grimshaw's complex-event/simple-event/result trichotomy separates nominals by argument structure: whether the noun takes obligatory arguments and aspectual modifiers. Simple event nominals (viagem, corrida, evento) fail those tests while remaining ontologically events, so the tests do not identify type (§4). They describe nominal syntax, not this classification.
A.5 quality and value do not distinguish causal origin#
Three reasons back the claim in §4 that causal origin plays no role in the
quality/value classification.
It duplicates the frame. Whether a producing event is on record is a fact
about the situation. Plain properties, actively maintained conditions and
resultant conditions are distinguished at the frame layer. That distinction
does not require separate quality or value lemma types.
Type and situation have different granularity. Quebrado can remain
value while its frame describes a resultant condition. This does not establish
that every participial reading belongs to that condition frame.
There is no reliable test. A distinction between a "resultant" quality (cansaço, force-maintained postura) and a non-resultant one (beleza, inteligĂȘncia) as a lemma-type opposition would re-lexicalize the stage-level/individual-level predicate distinction (Carlson 1977; Kratzer 1995), which is gradient, frequently ambiguous within a single predicate, and which the semantics literature declines to treat as an ontological sort.
Consequences: postura, cansaço â quality. Cansado, quebrado,
sentado â value. Anti-rigidity and causal origin are read off the frame.
A.6 Theoretical grounding for the procedural types#
The conceptual/procedural split is Relevance Theory's (§2). The nine subtypes are not â no RT publication proposes this inventory.
RT subdivides procedural meaning along two axes not used here: the target of the constraint (explicature, higher-level explicature, or implicature â Blakemore 1987; Wilson & Sperber 1993), and the cognitive subsystem the item triggers (Wilson 2011, 2016). The inventory here is organized by functional category instead, applying Escandell-Vidal & Leonetti's thesis that the semantics of functional categories is procedural. Their own enumeration â discourse markers, sentence-mood marks, quotative and evidential particles, intonation, verb tenses and moods, definite determiners and pronouns, deictic and focusing adverbs, information-structure devices â is a list, not a typology; the nine types coarsen that list into classes an annotator can assign.
| Type | Nearest published support | Status |
|---|---|---|
reference |
Wilson & Sperber 1993 on pronouns; Escandell-Vidal & Leonetti on definites and deictics | RT-aligned |
connection |
Blakemore's core case | RT-aligned |
focus |
focusing adverbs in Escandell-Vidal & Leonetti; Iten on concessives and even | RT-aligned |
interaction |
Wharton on interjections; CurcĂł on Spanish particles; quotative and evidential particles in Escandell-Vidal & Leonetti | RT-aligned |
predication |
the functional-category thesis | derived, not RT |
quantification |
only definite determiners are standardly procedural in RT | departure |
polarity |
classical RT gives nĂŁo/not a logical entry, i.e. conceptual | departure |
degree |
degree semantics (Kennedy; and GĂ€rdenfors for the scale) | outside RT |
modality |
RT treats only mood and modal particles as procedural | RT-aligned for mood/particles; local extension to auxiliaries (§5) |
quantification and polarity. Classical RT (Sperber & Wilson 1986, ch.
2) treats logical words as concepts with logical entries â a claim about how
an item enters inference. The criterion used here is narrower: does the
lemma name something the conceptualization inventory can hold? NĂŁo,
todo and nenhum have no dul: referent under any construal, and typing
them conceptually would require inventing one.
degree is not an RT category. The "region located against a standard"
criterion comes from degree semantics, and the dimension/region framing from
GĂ€rdenfors (§A.1). It is procedural because it instructs rather than names â
the operational test of §2.
modality. Wilson & Sperber (1993) and Ifantidou (1993, 2001) treat
sentence adverbials such as certamente and provavelmente as
conceptual; Papafragou (2000) treats modal verbs as conceptual. In RT
only mood and modal particles are procedural. FNBr's scalar adverbs are
value (§5, "modality vs value"), which keeps this row RT-aligned. One
residue: RT would also call the modal auxiliaries conceptual, following
Papafragou. They are kept procedural because no conceptual type fits them â
they name no scale, no event and no relation â and predication would
misdescribe them as contentless. Papafragou's own analysis supports the
single-lemma treatment of §5: one modal lexical entry per verb, with the
epistemic, deontic or ability flavour supplied by the context, as in
Kratzer.
What the inventory still lacks. Sentence mood and type (declarative,
interrogative, imperative) has no type of its own â currently spread across
reference (quem) and modality, with free-word mood markers landing in
interaction. Whether mood deserves its own type depends on how much of it
FNBr lexicalizes; mood realized by verb morphology or intonation is not a
lemma and is out of scope. Tense and aspect are procedural on most RT
accounts. Bound tense and aspect morphology is out of scope for the same
reason. Free-word aspect is covered in §5: auxiliaries are predication,
phase verbs are event, and the phasal particles ainda and jĂĄ are
quantification, following Löbner's analysis of them as phase quantifiers.
One RT axis considered and declined. Adding target â {explicature, higher-level explicature, implicature} as an orthogonal attribute would let
the scheme cite Wilson & Sperber (1993) directly. It is not adopted: the
target of a procedural constraint varies with use (the same connective can
strengthen or contradict), so the attribute would be a per-token judgement
recorded on a per-lemma row, and nothing consumes it.
A.7 modality vs interaction for evidentials#
Diz que is interaction on the grounds that it points at an information
source rather than stating speaker confidence. Some frameworks treat
evidentiality as a species of epistemic modality, which would put it with
modality. FNBr classifies evidential readings as
interaction across forms â diz que and the adverbs supostamente,
alegadamente, pretensamente, aparentemente, presumivelmente (§5).
The deciding point is that they direct the hearer to the source of the
information, which the speaker may not vouch for, rather than grading the
speaker's own confidence.
A.8 The cost of splitting adpositions#
Splitting moves work from the lexicon to the parser: the lexicon records a stable fact and the parser resolves a contextual one. That is the right direction, but it is a real cost and should be measured on the adposition tokens specifically, not averaged into overall lemma-resolution accuracy â see §A.9, item 9.
A.9 Open questions#
Recorded so they are not rediscovered as objections.
- Validation of
role. What inter-annotator agreement does the dependence test achieve on Portuguese data? The two corpus diagnostics in §4 give an external anchor; the number has not yet been measured. - Rigidity is not recorded. See §A.2.
- [U] is not used. Löbner's uniqueness feature distinguishes filho
(relational) from pai (functional) and predicts determination and
bridging behaviour. FNBr currently collapses both to
role. Whether [U] earns a column is open. - Dot objects.
objectdoes not represent the dual identity of livro (physical ⹠information) that co-predication exposes. Deferred, not solved. - POS à type correlation. How much independent information does the type layer carry over UPOS? One contingency table answers it (§1.5).
- The two-sort split has a boundary. Some lemmas plausibly encode both conceptually and procedurally (sempre, sĂł). The current rule assigns one type; whether that is adequate is untested.
- Split count. How many lemmas split under §1.4, and how concentrated is the count? A few dozen forms, dominated by adpositions, is the expected shape (§6.2). If splits are instead spread thinly across the content lexicon, the type inventory is drawing a line the lexicon does not observe, and the inventory â not the rule â needs revisiting.
- Relatedness between split lemmas is unrecorded. Negação act/operator
and pintura activity/canvas are separate rows with no link. Where the
relation matters it should be added explicitly at the lexical layer
(OntoLex-Lemon
vartrans). Whether it matters enough to build is open. - Adposition disambiguation accuracy. Splitting de, a, em, por, com and para by type (§6.2) moves their disambiguation to the parser, where UPOS cannot help because the candidates share it. Accuracy on adposition tokens should be measured separately, and the government heuristic evaluated on its own. If it underperforms badly, the alternatives are a richer valence-driven disambiguation or a coarser type inventory for adpositions â not a return to per-LU typing.
- The
modality/valueline needs validating, not deciding. The decision is taken (§5): scalar epistemic adverbs arevalue, talvez and the modal auxiliaries aremodality, on whether the lemma names a lexicalized dimension with a gradable counterpart. What is untested is coverage â whether every PB epistemic adverb falls cleanly on one side. Possivelmente and eventualmente are the likely stress cases, and eventualmente may not be epistemic at all in PB. Run the diagnostics over a closed list of epistemic adverbs before annotation opens. - The
modality/interactionboundary for evidentials. Evidential readings areinteraction(§A.7); coverage still requires validation. interactionhas not been tested at scale. It covers FNBr's pragmatic functions; its three boundaries â againstconnection,modalityandfocus(§5) â are stated but unvalidated. PB interactional particles are frequent and often multifunctional (tĂĄ as tag, as agreement token, as imperative of estar), so this type is the most likely source of new §1.4 splits.- The construal-shift diagnostic for substantivized adjectives is
unvalidated. The "recoverable covert sortal" test (§1.4) separates
productive ADJâN ellipsis (o bonito, um americano) from lexicalized
conversion (dependenteâ, and presumably empregado, acusado and
similar deverbal/deadjectival nouns). Coverage across the lexicon is
unmeasured. The "people by X"
@entityframes (§7) present a conventionalized middle case â a nationality, religion or vocation adjective defaults to a person referent systematically enough to be frame-licensed, yet no lemma split is made â and it is untested whether other systematic default-referent classes exist that the general test would miss. - Where the N de N relation lives. For kind D uses of de (§6.2), the relation could be a frame evoked by an N de N construction, peripheral FEs (Material, Possessor) added to the head frames, or a free relation R resolved pragmatically. §6.2 prefers the construction, but this needs testing on corpus data against the coverage of FNBr's constructicon.
- Recording what a preposition construes. In kinds B and C (§6.2), the FE comes from the head, but the preposition still has a construal: acreditar em and pensar em treat the content as a location; depender de treats it as a source, where English depend on treats it as support. The SNACS scheme (Schneider et al. 2018; Hwang et al. 2017) gives every adposition token two labels: a scene role, which in FrameNet terms is the FE, and a function, the adposition's own construal. An optional coarse function label on the annotation would record this at the annotation layer without adding LUs. Spatial schematic meanings (SOURCE for de, CONTAINMENT for em) could instead be recorded as image-schematic grounding, as for deictics (§6.1). Neither is adopted yet.
- Means por and instrument com. §6.2 treats por via oral as kind A
and cortou com a faca as kind C, yet many heads have a Means or
Instrument FE that either PP could fill. The working difference is that
means por also appears with nominals that do not select it (tentativa
de suicĂdio por ingesta) and has a
relationneighbour in através de. Whether that holds across the corpus, or whether instrument com should follow, is untested.