Classifying Frames

Namespaces#

Every accepted frame belongs to exactly one namespace. Its namespace classifies how the frame presents its defined situation, referent or modeling function—not the POS of its LUs or the possible fillers of one FE.

Use the definition, FE semantics and frame relations, supported by representative LU readings and annotations. A name or a majority of lemma types cannot determine the answer. Some namespaces distinguish coarse perspectives on an event; they do not encode every fine construal.

Namespaces and domains#

Namespaces and domains are orthogonal. The namespace says how a frame presents its content: the participant perspective on a situation, the structure of a property's scale, or the type of a relation. The domain says what the content is about: emotion, health, law, space. Breaking a vase and persuading a voter are both Agentive; a part-whole relation can concern a body, a building or an organization.

A namespace should therefore take frames from several domains, and the frames of one subdomain should spread over several namespaces. A proposed namespace that coincides with a domain or subdomain duplicates the domain dimension and should be redesigned.

The namespace inventory#

There are twenty-six documented frame namespaces. Four labels group them into families: eventive (with Experiential inside it), Attribute and Relation. A family label is not a namespace value. This inventory defines the model; it does not certify that every stored frame is correctly classified.

Family Namespace Positive criterion
Eventive Agentive An initiator performs an activity or causes a result; intentional Agent or non-intentional Cause.
Eventive Change An entity enters a different condition or undergoes a directed shift, without foregrounding the initiator.
Eventive Undergoing Affectedness under an inherent but backgrounded external instigator.
Eventive Phenomenon A bare occurrence, after more specific eventive criteria have been excluded.
Eventive State An entity being in a stable situation: maintained, resultant or general (e.g. existence, being at risk). Applies after the Attribute, Relation and Experiential families are excluded.
Experiential Experiencer_state An experiencer is in a psychological or sensory condition that holds.
Experiential Experiential_change An experiencer enters or leaves a psychological or sensory condition.
Experiential Mental_activity An experiencer carries out a mental or perceptual process, usually controlled and extended in time.
Experiential Stimulus_oriented The stimulus or content is profiled: it brings an experience about or is described by the experience it evokes.
— Entity A kind of entity or participant rather than its action, property or a relation considered as such.
— Quality A quality named as such: an aspect inhering in a bearer, profiled as the dimension rather than as a value ascribed to the bearer.
Attribute Gradable A bearer has a position on a scale that holds against a relative or absolute standard.
Attribute Measured_value A value given as a quantity: a count of units, a number, a ratio, a sum, or the unit itself.
Attribute Classifying A non-gradable property places the bearer in a category of a dimension.
Attribute Modal A property of a single bearer defined by what can, must, should or tends to happen with it.
Attribute Modifier The LUs modify another predicate (degree, approximation, manner) instead of describing an entity.
Relation Localization A figure placed relative to a ground or landmark, in space or in time.
Relation Part_membership A part and its whole, a subset or member and its set or group, a remainder and its source.
Relation Classification_identity An instance related to a type, a category or another instance.
Relation Comparison_ordering Relata set against each other or against a standard, or placed in a sequence.
Relation Dependency One situation conditions, requires, explains, indicates or serves another.
Relation Association A holding tie between participants defined by complementary or shared roles.
— Structural A schematic conceptual structure used as grounding/scaffolding.
— Microframe A reusable binary relation reified as a frame, with Domain and Range arguments.
— Class A frame representing a DUL class, rather than a lexical situation.
— Pragmatic Discourse/interaction management, stance or deictic reference as a communicative operation.

Class is not a synonym for Entity, and Quality is not a namespace of the Attribute family: it has no value structure of its own, which belongs to the frames that ascribe the values. Structural and Microframe require an explicit modeling function; abstraction or two FEs alone is insufficient.

In the database, a namespace's name carries its family as a prefix: Eventive.Agentive, Experiential.Experiencer_state, Attribute.Gradable, Relation.Localization. Experiential_change is stored as Experiential.Change. State, Entity, Quality, Structural, Microframe, Class and Pragmatic have no prefix. Code that keys on a namespace must use the stored name.

The former Experiential, Attribute and Relation namespaces were each split into the namespaces of their family (database/sql/namespace_refine.sql). Their database rows remain, without frames, until they are deleted.

Classification procedure#

  1. Identify what the frame describes. Separate lexical situations and referents from discourse operations and explicitly designated scaffolding/class objects.
  2. Distinguish a participant category from its associated event or relation. FNBr places agentive names in Entity frames; their event participation is recorded separately. In the same way, distinguish a quality named as such from the ascription of its values: a frame naming the quality (morality, sexuality) is Quality, a frame ascribing a value to a bearer is in the Attribute family (step 4).
  3. Apply the psychological-domain gate before aspect, control or causation. Sentience alone is insufficient. When psychological or sensory content with a sentient experiencer is constitutive, the frame belongs to the Experiential family; choose its namespace by perspective: a condition holding (Experiencer_state), a condition being entered or left (Experiential_change), a controlled mental or perceptual process (Mental_activity), or the stimulus profiled (Stimulus_oriented). Which faculty is involved (emotion, perception, cognition, memory) is recorded by the domain, not the namespace. An agent acting on someone else's experience remains Agentive.
  4. For nonpsychological conditions, count the relata among the core FEs. A single bearer with a property or value belongs to the Attribute family, even when a standard or comparison set is mentioned; choose by the structure of the value: Gradable, Measured_value, Classifying, Modal or Modifier. Two relata (Figure and Ground, Instance and Type, Owner and Possession, Dependent and Requirement) place the frame in the Relation family; choose by relation type. An entity being in a stable situation, whether maintained, resultant or general, is State. Do not invent a force from general world knowledge.
  5. For dynamic situations, compare initiation/action (Agentive), externally imposed affectedness (Undergoing) and transition/directed shift, including gradual change (Change). A multi-phase scenario has no namespace of its own: apply the same comparison to what its definition foregrounds.
  6. Use Phenomenon only as a supported residual. Missing information means defer, not Phenomenon.
  7. Check all the evidence. Mixed situations may require separate frames or LU readings, not one namespace replacement.

Grammar is supporting evidence. Passive voice, subject choice, ser/estar/ficar, progressive or imperative compatibility, duration and argument count are not automatic namespace gates. Implicit participants still count. A contextual construction can add a path, cause or result without changing the lexical frame of its target.

Situations and conceptual grounding#

The DUL distinction between Event and Situation allows several views of one happening without identifying lexical records with that happening. FNBr models the eventive categories as Situation kinds: AgentiveSituation, UndergoingSituation, ExperientialSituation (for the whole Experiential family), PhenomenonSituation and StativeSituation, with Change aligned to Transition. These are grounding correspondences, not Berkeley namespace categories or evidence that all database links are populated.

A frame's conceptual schema describes the structure against which its meaning is interpreted. The namespace and grounding schema are distinct axes. In particular, State covers active maintenance, resultant conditions and general stable situations; shared attributive structure does not erase producing-event dependence where it exists.

Perspective and frame families#

Agentive, Undergoing and Change may distinguish initiation, affectedness and transition within an event family. This is a semantic contrast, not a subject/voice alternation rule. The Experiential family applies the same contrast inside the psychological domain: causing an emotion (Stimulus_oriented), entering it (Experiential_change) and experiencing it (Experiencer_state) are distinct frames in distinct namespaces.

A legitimate perspective pair does not establish that a particular LU belongs in either member. Preserve each reading's participant structure and lexical contribution. Agentive/inchoative links and Perspective_on links have distinct meanings; do not create one merely because the other could connect a pair.

The FrameNet patterns page gives the verified requirements for frame separation, neutral perspectives, event/state families and participant associations.

Scenarios and modality#

Scenario is a frame type, not a namespace. A scenario has a namespace based on its own definition; do not inherit the namespace from one perspectivized child. A scenario that organizes phases is classified by what its definition foregrounds: an initiator carrying the phases out is Agentive (Criminal_process, Commerce_scenario), an entity passing through them is Change (Cycle_of_life_and_death, Motion_scenario), an experiencer's states are Experiencer_state (Sleep_wake_cycle), and an unfolding with no profiled participant is Phenomenon (Process). In a phase schema the boundaries are Change, causing them is Agentive and the continuation is State. See Frame classification.

Modality is classified by its relata, not by a namespace of its own. Classify the defined meaning:

Meaning Classification guidance
Possibility, probability or requirement of a single situation, without a Cognizer Modal
Capability or propensity as an entity's property Modal, unless a more specific experiential or relational meaning is constitutive
Obligation or requirement relating two core relata (a party and a duty, a dependent and a requirement) Dependency
A thinker's confidence or belief Experiencer_state
Imposing a duty as an action Agentive
Speaker's discourse management or stance display Pragmatic when the communicative operation itself is profiled

Boundaries requiring explicit review#

The following are not settled by a word-level example or by the types of the lemmas involved:

  • Gradual Change versus Undergoing or Phenomenon, phase manipulation, caused processes and unbounded directed motion.
  • State versus Gradable or Classifying for health, vital state, origin and social/legal status, and for conditions that sit in causative/inchoative families.
  • Attribute versus Relation family when a standard, comparison set or type might be a second core relatum.
  • Gradable versus Classifying for frames whose LUs mix gradable and categorical readings (colour, frequency, body description).
  • Experiencer_state versus Experiential_change or Mental_activity for frames whose LUs mix holding, entering and doing (remembering and forgetting; holding and voicing a judgment).
  • Experiencer_state versus Gradable for general traits/dispositions where psychological content is unclear.
  • Lexical versus scaffolding uses, microframe lexicalization and underspecified neutral scenarios.

For these cases, document the alternatives and missing evidence and defer the affected assignment. Do not assign two namespaces to one frame. Lemma types do not restrict LU allocation by namespace (Lemmas §8). Namespace criteria do not authorize automatic LU moves, retyping or merges.