Change Namespace

Core definition#

Change frames profile an entity entering a different condition or undergoing a directed shift, without foregrounding the initiator. The semantic focus is the transition, not the causing action and not the condition simply holding afterward.

Pattern Meaning Constructed example
Result transition Becoming different in a relevant respect O vaso quebrou.
Dimensional shift Movement between positions on a spatial or abstract dimension Maria chegou ao destino.; A igreja virou um clube.
BECOME(Condition(Theme))
SHIFT(Theme, Initial, Final, Dimension)

A frame need not express both endpoints as FEs. A change can have a cause in the world without profiling it. “Self-contained change” does not mean “physically uncaused.”

Scope and boundaries#

  • Physical/material change, configurational change, category transition and directed displacement can qualify.
  • Agentive profiles bringing about the change: JoĂŁo abriu a porta versus a porta abriu. Passive voice does not by itself remove the causing subevent.
  • Undergoing profiles subjection to an externally instigated affecting event, rather than the transition alone. Affected subject or recoverable cause alone cannot distinguish them.
  • The Experiential family takes precedence for constitutive cognition, perception, emotion or felt sensation: coming to believe and becoming frightened remain psychological meanings.
  • State profiles a maintained or resultant condition: being broken is not breaking. Resultant conditions are included in State when producing-event dependence is part of their meaning.
  • The Attribute family profiles a plain property; the Relation family a holding connection. Estar alone decides neither.
  • Phenomenon is a bare-occurrence residual. Spontaneous ripening is not Phenomenon merely because no Agent is mentioned when transition/result is constitutive.

Internal distinctions#

A transition may concern a situation, a quality, a category, existence or location. Preserve differences in permitted FE types, initial/final conditions and entailed stages. The FrameNet book's §§2.1.1–2.1.3 support this review; they do not prescribe one namespace for every verb or construction.

Telic transitions are central examples, but do not use em X tempo as a necessary condition for the entire namespace. Directed yet unbounded shifts and gradual progression (developing, progressing through stages) are Change when the entity's position on a dimension shifts; compare Undergoing where an affecting force is constitutive (Aging) and Phenomenon where only the unfolding is profiled. Adding a Goal phrase to correr does not automatically reclassify its LU: determine whether the lexical target or the construction supplies the path.

Motion. A frame that profiles a Theme changing location (from a Source, along a Path, to a Goal or in a Direction) without profiling a self-mover or a causer is Change: a bola rolou até o muro, a água escorreu pelo ralo. Fictive motion of light or sound and a passenger carried by a vehicle are treated the same way. A living being moving under its own direction is Agentive (o menino correu até a praça), and a motion scenario taken as ordered phases (setting out, travelling, arriving) stays Change while no self-mover is profiled. Motion with no change of location and no self-directed mover (rotating, vibrating, shaking in place) is Phenomenon (v1.5).

Phase meanings#

Distinguish four different contributions:

Meaning Review question
Starting, finishing or resuming Is a boundary transition itself profiled?
Causing a process to start or stop Is an initiator's action profiled?
Continuing Is persistence/maintenance profiled (State), or the unfolding itself?
Lasting a specified time Is the frame measuring temporal extent rather than describing maintenance?

These contrasts guide comparison with Change, Agentive, State, Phenomenon and the Relation/Attribute families; they are not a word-to-namespace lookup table. Defer phase frames whose definition leaves the distinction unresolved.

In a phase schema (start, continue, pause, resume, stop) the boundary transitions are Change, causing them is Agentive and the continuation is State. A scenario that binds the phases together takes the namespace of what its own definition foregrounds; an entity passing through ordered stages (Change_of_phase_scenario, Cycle_of_existence_scenario) is Change.

Characteristic signature#

Participant Typical contribution
Patient / Theme Entity whose condition or position differs
Initial / Source Starting condition or position, when represented
Final / Result / Goal Reached condition or position; distinguish an intended destination from an achieved one
Path / Dimension Route or dimension of the shift, when represented

A missing overt FE does not establish that its semantic contribution is absent. Read core status and null instantiation in the actual frame, not from this template.

Conceptual grounding#

The CHANGE schema represents the locus as Antagonist, the dimension as Ground, before/after positions as Income/Outcome, and the projected destination as Target. TRANSITION specializes category crossing; MOTION specializes displacement. Schema elements and lexical FEs require explicit alignment.

Review diagnostics#

Determine which difference is entailed, whether the change or its cause is profiled, and what persists afterward. Compare actual examples and participant structure, not se, subject position or a participial paraphrase alone. Defer unresolved gradual-change, path/activity and phase boundaries.

See FrameNet patterns for causative/inchoative/state relations and inheritance guidance. A missing same-verb causative does not establish the absence of a semantically related causative frame.